Neural and humoral control of muscle atrophy

Thesis / Dissertation

1998

Permanent link to this Item
Authors
Supervisors
Journal Title
Link to Journal
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Publisher

University of Cape Town

License
Series
Abstract
The aim of this thesis was to examine the relative input of neural activity changes and humoral factors in the control of muscle atrophy, which is a consequence of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficiency. The first study was an epidemiological investigation of injuries in the Cape Town sporting community. Two hundred and sixty questionnaires were randomly distributed to individuals involved in a variety of different sports, in order to assess the incidence of sport-induced injuries, nature of the injuries and rehabilitation modalities used. Injuries occurred in most anatomical regions, with the knee joint being involved in 18% of injuries. The majority of respondents went directly to a physiotherapist after suffering their injuries. In contrast, no injuries were treated by a biokineticist. and 47% of respondents were unsure of the role of the biokineticist. Twenty two percent of respondents were dissatisfied with the treatment of their sporting injuries. It was concluded that the multi-disciplinary approach to sport injury management was not being correctly utilised in the Cape Town community. The second study was an epidemiological investigation of techniques used by Orthopaedic surgeons for repair and rehabilitation of ACL injuries. Four hundred and seventy five questionnaires were distributed to all Orthopaedic surgeons in South Africa. A 77% questionnaire return rate occurred. A significantly higher proportion of state hospital respondents used standard or modified parapatellar arthrotomy procedures rather than arthroscopy techniques when compared to private respondents (p < 0.01 ). Similarly, the majority of these surgeons preferred to immobilise the damaged limb for 6 weeks or longer as compared to private surgeons, who more often would use accelerated rehabilitation schedules. The large majority of all respondents (79%) used bone-patellar tendon-bone grafts as their material of choice for ACL replacement. It was concluded that registrar Orthopaedic surgeons may be learning techniques different to those used in the private sector, and that this concern could be resolved by involving the private sector Orthopaedic surgeons in registrar training where deficiencies existed. The third study was an epidemiological investigation of pneumatic tourniquet use and 11 perceptions of complications which may arise from tourniquet use. The subjects in this study were the same Orthopaedic surgeons described above in study two. Although the large proportion of respondents were aware of the hazards of excessive duration of tourniquet use and the complications of subsequent underlying muscle ischaemia, a large proportion of respondents used high tourniquet inflation pressures and were not as aware of the side effects of tourniquet pressure in causing side effects. It was similarly found that those subjects who did not believe the pneumatic tourniquet caused underlying complications did not check the pneumatic tourniquet apparatus as regularly as those respondents who were aware of the possibility of complications. It was concluded that this finding was of some concern because of the fact that a number of studies have shown that malfunctioning gauges can under-read the true pressure significantly, and because it has been demonstrated that a large proportion of hospital tourniquet apparatuses are faulty in certain hospitals. The fourth study was a study of anthropometrical and isokinetic quadriceps and hamstrings strength and endurance capacity in normal subjects (n=10), and an assessment of the relationship between these variables tested. A strong correlation was found between lean thigh volume (LTV) and both quadriceps and hamstrings isokinetic concentric and eccentric peak torque and total work capacity for both maximal strength and endurance capacity testing. This was particularly evident for the relationship between quadriceps eccentric peak torque capacity and LTV (r=0.98). There were no significant differences between limbs for all variables tested. The fifth study examined functional, anthropometrical and strength deficits in chronic ACL deficient subjects. There were significantly lower LTV and isokinetic strength measurements in the ACL deficient limb compared to the normal limb (n=20). The eccentric component of strength testing was particularly affected, showing lower values for eccentric peak torque than concentric peak torque. The relationship between LTV and eccentric peak torque was lower than that elicited both in normal subjects (r=0.66) and that elicited in the normal contralateral limb. These changes were reflected in changes in the subjects' lifestyle, with the majority of subjects having to downgrade their lifestyle, and a number experiencing frequent episodes of giving way or collapse of the ACL deficient limb. It was concluded that the loss of the quadriceps muscle size was not the only responsible factor for eccentric peak torque losses, and that perhaps a protective neural inhibition of quadriceps function, and particularly maximal eccentric contraction during ballistic isokinetic testing, exists. The sixth study examined subjects with partial (n=7) as compared to complete (n=12) chronic ACL deficiency. Both partial and complete groups showed similar inhibition of quadriceps eccentric function, and it was thus concluded that this functional loss may be related to anterior tibial translation in the damaged ACL limb rather than loss of the ACL itself. It was also found that hamstrings strength was greater in the complete ACL deficient subjects compared to partial ACL deficient subjects, which indicates that in the ACL deficient limb the hamstrings act to a greater degree as secondary stabilisers of the knee joint preventing anterior tibial translation . The seventh study examined subjects whose ACL had been repaired at least a year or more previously (n=8}. Despite these subjects having improved subjective functional ratings, the correlation between the ACL reconstructed quadriceps eccentric peak torque and LTV was similar to that in the ACL deficient limb (r=0.50), and significantly decreased eccentric peak torque capacity in the affected limb. This finding indicated that ACL reconstruction does not improve quadriceps strength function and strengthened the hypothesis of a mechanoreceptor mediated quadriceps inhibitory mechanism. The eighth study examined subjects in the acute phase after ACL rupture (n=6), to assess whether these changes were a chronic adaptation to ACL deficiency or occurred directly as a consequence of the injury. In these subjects an almost identical pattern of anthropometrical and isokinetic strength deficits occurred as in the chronic ACL deficient and ACL groups. This finding indicated that these strength deficits were nor a late-onset compensatory mechanism but occurred directly as a result of the ACL rupture. Similarly, these findings were unlikely to have been caused simply by pain-induced nociceptor stimulation, as they remained present in the pain free, chronic ACL deficient subjects described earlier. The ninth study examined the underlying muscular pathology in the acutely injured ACL subjects described earlier (n=6). Compared to control subjects (n=10), the ACL deficient subjects demonstrated visible type I and type II muscle fibre atrophy associated with fibrosis, fibre degeneration and vacuolar degeneration. Although both fibre types were damaged, type I fibres were atrophied to a greater degree, with the ratio of type I/type II fibres decreasing. Similarly, citrate synthase activity decreased while phosphofructokinase activity increased. 13 This indicated that either neural firing patterns in the musculature were altered, that piezo- electric humeral signals induced by inactivity, or a combination of both these factors caused pathological changes in the underlying musculature. The presence of angulated fibres and fibre splitting, both pathognomonic of denervation atrophy, were observed in the ACL damaged subjects muscle samples, indicating that perhaps neural activity pattern changes are more responsible for the changes in the musculature. The tenth study examined the effects of ACL resection, immobilisation and denervation on underlying musculature in a rat model (n=72). In the ACL resected group, similar changes to the human group was found, with fibrosis, fibre degeneration and angulated and split fibres present in both superficial and deep vastus rat muscles. In this rat model, both fibre types showed atrophy, with type I fibres showing a greater degree of atrophy than type II fibres. Similar findings occurred in rats whose femoral nerve was resected. In contrast, both type I and type II fibres were severely and equally affected in spica-immobilised rats, and none of these changes occurred in sham-operated rats. It was concluded that ACL resection, in the absence of any other pathological intervention, leads to quadriceps muscle atrophy which resembles a denervation rather than an immobilisation atrophy. The eleventh study examined neural activity pattern changes during eccentric quadriceps muscular activity in ACL deficient (n=20), ACL repaired (n=8) and recently injured (n=6) ACL subjects using electromyography (EMG) techniques. In the vastus medialis musculature, the neural activity patterns were unequivocally altered, with less neural activation of the underlying musculature. It was noted that these changes were present only in eccentric activity, while during concentric muscle function no significant changes occurred. This indicated that these EMG changes could not be caused by altered signals occurring in damaged muscle, as the concentric component was normal. These findings strongly support the theory that a neural inhibitory pathway rather than humeral piezo-electric changes, are primarily responsible for the LTV changes, strength deficits and muscle pathology described earlier. The twelfth study examined quantitative and qualitative changes in EMG activity during step down activity in ACL deficient (n=20); ACL repaired (n=8) and recently injured (n=6) ACL subjects. Surprisingly, there were no significant qualitative and quantitative changes in the ACL group. Rather, gait pattern changes were found in the ACL repaired group. This group 14 demonstrated an avoidance pattern of movement, with the normal limb being activated to a greater degree during step down activity, perhaps to unload the affected limb. These findings indicated that different mechanisms are involved in these changes compared to the quadriceps inhibition response described earlier, one being a complex excitatory response and the other a reflexive inhibitory response. One must speculate that perhaps multiple different pathways are activated by ACL damage, some of which are permanent reflex responses and others learned response modification induced by the subsequent reconstruction and rehabilitation. In summary, this thesis describes neural activity changes in the quadriceps musculature of ACL deficient subjects with associated eccentric isokinetic strength deficits and a dissociation in the strong relationship between LTV and strength capacity described in normal subjects. These changes are not altered by ACL reconstruction, and occur in the acute phase after ACL injury. These neural activity changes induce pathological fibre atrophy in the underlying quadriceps musculature which are a consequence rather than a cause of the altered neural activity patterns. Gait pattern changes in ACL reconstructed subjects during step down activity indicate that there may be more than one neural recruitment pattern changes induced by ACL damage, reconstruction and subsequent rehabilitation.
Description

Reference:

Collections