Hard hitting facts on childhood head trauma: an epidemiological analysis

Ferreira, Yolandi

Hard hitting facts on childhood head trauma: an epidemiological analysis

Master Thesis

2019

Abstract

Background: According to the World Health Organization (WHO), Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) will become the third largest cause of global disease by the year 2020. Despite its astonishing numbers, TBI remains a silent or even forgotten epidemic with significant paucity in epidemiological data. TBI in developing countries represents a disproportionate burden of disease and data are lacking regarding the unique demographics in South Africa to design and implement focused prevention programmes. A valuable tool to assess the severity of TBI is the use of Computer tomography (CT). CT also is the main imaging modality to provide rapid identification and information for the management of children with TBI. CT scanning utilises ionising radiation and as an imaging modality poses risk to the patient. In order to guide decision protocol/algorithm, various Clinical Decision Rules (CDRs) have been established in High Income Countries. These protocols, including the need for CT scan might differ in a Medium/Low Income setting. Methodology: This is a prospective, single centre cohort study. Data were collected over an 18-month period (1 August 2015 - 31 January 2017). Children under the age of 13 years (n=3007) presenting to RCWCH after sustaining a head injury were included. Various epidemiological data were collected. A Road Safety Questionnaire was also used to evaluate safety knowledge of health care workers. Three different CDRs were compared to the standard of practice in RCWCH. A final analysis of demographics, mechanism of injury, radiology outcome, safety analysis and evaluation of a comparison of local protocol compared to the other CDRs was performed using descriptive statistics. Results: The mean age of paediatric patients presenting after a head injury was 4.6 years. There was a significant male predominance (66%) and almost two thirds of all children were of pre-school age. Falls (53%; n=1601) represented the most common mechanism of injury across all age groups, followed by road traffic related injuries (RTI) (29%; n=864), struck by or against an object (9%; n=279) and injuries as a result of interpersonal violence (8%; n=230). Within the subset of RTI (n=864) only 6 passengers were appropriately restrained, with 142 unrestrained and 56 passengers transported on the back of a goods vehicle. In the under 3-yearold age group, only 1 patient was appropriately transported in a car seat, with 51 unrestrained and 6 transported on the back of a goods vehicle. Pedestrian related injuries were by far the largest group of RTI (70%) with 50% of these under the age of 5 years. Intentional injuries inflicted by an adult were most common (34%) in the pre-verbal (under 2 years old) group. Interpersonal violence among minors (assault with a brick or stone) constituted 52% of intentional injuries. Eight firearm related injuries were recorded. Appliances and iron gates that were not correctly installed were additional causes of injury. CT scans were obtained according to the RCWCH protocol in 59% of cases and 34% showed an abnormal result. The sensitivity (98%) and specificity (93%) while using the standard of practice protocol was better than the 3 CDRs developed in High Income Countries. Analysing our Road Safety Questionnaire there appears great room for improvement regarding awareness of road safety guidelines and legislation. Conclusion: The performance of the current RCWCH CT scan protocol appears appropriate in our setting although there is some room for improvement using the strengths of the other CDRs. Valuable insight regarding the epidemiology of TBI in our setting has been highlighted. Of specific importance is the large proportion of very young children at risk of injury by all mechanisms of injury, particularly pedestrian-related injuries, unrestrained passengers and interpersonal violence among minors. Important gaps in knowledge about current recommendations for road safety were identified by the questionnaire. As long as these issues are not appropriately addressed through enhanced injury prevention programmes, children will continue to carry the heavy burden of TBI morbidity and mortality.

Keywords

general surgery

Reference:

Collections

Masters

Full item page