Exercise-associated muscle cramps in distance runners: the role of serum electrolytes both during and following an ultra marathon and IEMG activity in the recovery phase post-cramp
Thesis / Dissertation
1996
Permanent link to this Item
Authors
Supervisors
Journal Title
Link to Journal
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Publisher
University of Cape Town
Faculty
License
Series
Abstract
Exercise associated muscle cramps (EAMC) is a serious condition that can interfere with athletic performance. The scientific literature reveals very little well documented published research on the aetiology, pathophysiology, prevention and management of the condition. For the purposes of this thesis, EAMC is defined as involuntary, painful, electrically active and visible contraction of skeletal muscle, that is of sudden onset, lasts for seconds to minutes and occurs during or within 24 hours of a bout of exercise. The historical perspective, epidemiology, risk factors for EAMC, pathophysiology, prevention and management of EAMC are discussed initially. The hypothesis in the first study is that EAMC is not associated with serum electrolyte concentrations and hydration status. In this study, a group of 72 runners competing in the 56 km Two Oceans Marathon were prospectively studied to determine whether acute EAMC in distance runners is related to serum electrolyte concentrations and hydration status. This group of 72 runners consisted of a group of 45 runners who regularly suffer EAMC (Chronic Crampers) and a group of 27 runners with a history of no previous EAMC (Non-cramping group). Of the original cohort of 72 runners, 21 runners suffered EAMC during of within 60 minutes of completing the race (EAMC group) and 23 runners suffered no EAMC during or within 60 minutes of completing the race (CON group). Twenty-eight runners were excluded for not following the protocol. Body weight (BW) was measured and blood samples for blood glucose, serum electrolyte concentrations, serum osmolality, haemoglobin and haematocrit were collected from all runners 75 mins before the race and immediately on completion of the race and 60 mins after the race (T 50). Both groups had similar (mean± SD), age (years), (CON : 42 ± 8, EAMC : 37 ± 8), pre-race BW (kg) (CON : 73 ± 8, EAMC : 78 ± 11 ), and race finishing times (min) (CON : 304 ± 36, EAMC : 309 ± 41 ). Runners with EAMC were treated only with rest, passive stretching and oral fluids, and all were cramp free by T60. Serum electrolyte concentrations (mmol/I), blood glucose(mmol/I), osmolality (mosm/I) and hydration status (calculated as % change in BW (% BWC) and % change in plasma volume (%PVC) were compared in the EAMC and CON groups. There were no significant differences in the serum electrolyte concentrations, blood glucose, osmolality and hydration status between the EAMC (%BWC: -2.9 ±1 .2, %PVC: 0.2 ± 6.3) and the CON (%BWC: -3.6 ±1 .2, %PVC: -0.7 ± 8.6) group. The results of this study support the hypothesis that EAMC is not associated with in serum electrolyte concentrations and hydration status. The hypothesis of the second study is that recovery from an acute EAMC in distance runners will be associated with a decrease in integrated electromyographic (IEMG) activity, while demonstrating no association with to serum electrolyte concentrations. Eleven subjects with acute severe EAMC after a 56km race were compared to controls (Control elec, n=11) for serum electrolyte concentrations and Controls (Control EMG, n = 7) for IEMG activity. Controls for the serum electrolyte concentrations (Control elec) were runners matched for age, gender and finishing time who completed the 56 km race without EAMC. Controls for the IEMG (Control EMG) were runners with no EAMC after a 35km run. IEMG was recorded 1) in the affected muscle (quadriceps (Q), gastrocnemius (G)) of the subjects in the EAMC group on admission (To) and after recovery (T60) during periods when the runners were not experiencing a spontaneous muscle contraction and ii) in the Control (EMG) group in the Q and G muscles after the 35km run and 60 min later (T60). EMG data was expressed as% change in IEMG (TO to T60). There was no significant difference in the EAMC group and control group with respect to initial and 60-minute post-race serum electrolyte concentration. The % decrease (mean(SD) (To vs T 60) in IEMG for the EAMC group (52 ± 25) was significantly greater (p<0.05) than the Control (EMG) group (12~7). The results support the hypothesis that, i) EAMC is associated with a decrease in IEMG activity during recovery from EAMC), ii) there is no association between recovery from EAMC and serum electrolyte concentrations. This study also indicated that during the post-race period runners with EAMC have greater baseline IEMG activity than control runners. The third study examines the effects of passive stretching on IEMG activity during acute episodes of EAMC in four distance runners. This study demonstrates i) increased IEMG activity during an acute EAMC, ii) that passive stretching is associated with a rapid decrease in IEMG activity during an acute EAMC, iii) increased baseline IEMG activity in the cramping muscle between acute episodes of cramping. Conclusion: Serum electrolyte concentrations and hydration status are dissociated from EAMC before and after the race and during the recovery period of EAMC. Recovery from EAMC is associated with decreased IEMG activity in the involved muscle. Passive stretching of a muscle in acute EAMC is associated with a rapid decrease in IEMG activity of that muscle.
Description
Reference:
Nicol, J.C.H. 1996. Exercise-associated muscle cramps in distance runners: the role of serum electrolytes both during and following an ultra marathon and IEMG activity in the recovery phase post-cramp. . University of Cape Town ,Faculty of Health Sciences ,Division of Exercise Science and Sports Medicine. http://hdl.handle.net/11427/43870