Browsing by Subject "Water Quality Engineering"
Now showing 1 - 9 of 9
Results Per Page
Sort Options
- ItemOpen AccessA Comparison of Wastewater Process Modelling Tools: Case Study of Potsdam WWTW(2022) Govender, Neeren; Ikumi, DavidA wastewater process model can either be based on a steady-state or dynamic mathematical modelling approach. The characterisation of the influent wastewater and specific wastewater parameters are critical input parameters to the mathematical model, whether for design, optimisation or to measure the expected performance of a wastewater treatment works (WWTW). A wastewater treatment process is inherently dynamic because of the changes in wastewater characteristics and flow rates, impacting the plant's process capacity and performance. Mathematical models have the capability to model such changes with ease and predict the expected performance of the plant. This dissertation involves a theoretical modelling approach to compare steady-state and dynamic-state modelling tools on an existing full-scale WWTW, namely the Potsdam WWTW located in Cape Town (South Africa). The models adopted for this research included: i) A plant-wide steady-state model developed by the Author as part of this dissertation (Author's PWM); ii) Plant-Wide Steady-State Design (PWSSD) developed by Wu (2014); iii) BioWin 5.0 (developed by Envirosim Associates Ltd; Barker and Dold, 1997; Envirosim 2007); and iv) UCTPHO dynamic model (Wentzel et al., 1992). The goal was to compare the output and results of the various models adopted for this research under steady-state and dynamic-state conditions where the models have been calibrated on historical field data and to examine the impact that specific wastewater characteristics have on the process capacity and the overall performance of the WWTW. To accomplish this goal, the following objectives were achieved: 1. The characterisation of the influent wastewater is critical in modelling. For a new plant (green field site), the wastewater characterisation will be based on typical norms as published in the relevant research literature. For an existing plant, the wastewater characterisation is typically based on historical sampling data. There can be challenges with historical sampling data, as data is often not measured, missing or not credible. In this case, designers are required to make assumptions to fill the gaps in the wastewater characterisation, adopting typical norms as published in the research literature and using sound process engineering judgement which was the scenario for the case study WWTW. 2. The documented design capacity of the Potsdam WWTW is 47 Mℓ/day (47,000 kgCOD/day) whereas the total theoretical process capacity estimated as part of this dissertation is 60.75 Mℓ/day (64,660 kgCOD/day), 37.5% higher than the documented process capacity. 3. The various models correlated well in terms of output results for both steady-state and dynamic-state conditions when compared across all process units for both the liquid and sludge streams, using the same input process parameters (flow rates, load patterns, wastewater characterisation, fractions and design assumptions). The steady-state models (Author's PWM and PWSSD) were almost identical in output results except for the aerobic digester. The output results of the dynamic-state models (BioWin and UCTPHO) were similar to the steady-state models but did differ for a few variables, attributed to the fact that the dynamic models use dynamic kinetic equations under constant or dynamic flow and load conditions, and this will produce different results than the less complex steady-state models which are based on constant flow and load conditions. 4. An evaluation of the impact of selected influent characteristic parameters on the system performance variables for biological nutrient (nitrogen and phosphorus) removal was performed for each of the steady-state and dynamicstate models. The parameters selected included the influent TKN (TKN/COD ratio), the maximum specific growth rate of nitrifiers (µMax) and readily biodegradable COD (RBCOD), and during the analysis, all other input parameters to the models were kept constant. The influent TKN and RBCOD are specific wastewater characteristics that can vary during the lifetime of a WWTW having a strong impact on its N and P removal performance. µMax is also a critical wastewater parameter and at sludge ages close to the minimum sludge age for nitrification, this parameter impacts severely on the performance of biological nitrogen removal systems. It was concluded that substantial changes in the influent TKN, µMax and RBCOD will significantly impact a WWTW, specifically concerning N and P removal, therefore, impacting effluent and sludge quality. The various models followed similar trends; however, the following discrepancies were noted: ▪ When the TKN was increased, only the BioWin model considered the impact that the pH outside the range of 7.2 – 8.0 would have on the µMax and nitrification capacity of the bioreactor. This is a shortfall in the other models ▪ When the µMax was varied, the different models followed the same trend, but nitrification problems occurred at different µMax values. The BioWin model showed partial nitrification at a higher µMax threshold value than the other models, which occurred under minimum temperature conditions only ▪ When the RBCOD was varied, the only difference in the models is the RBCOD fraction at which complete biological phosphate removal took place. The steady-state models had the same RBCOD fraction, and the dynamic-state model (i.e., BioWin) had a higher RBCOD fraction at which complete biological phosphorous removal took place due to the fact that BioWin adopts two different maximum specific growth rates for the poly accumulating organisms (PAOs), namely a higher growth rate constant under phosphorous rich conditions which results in a higher uptake of phosphorous, and a lower growth rate constant under phosphorous limited conditions, where phosphorous uptake is limited. With a lower PAO growth in the BioWin model resulting in a lower PAO population, there is less potential for aerobic polyphosphate uptake, resulting in higher effluent Ortho-P concentrations. A WWTW is complex with many interactions of different processes (biological, chemical and physical) and products taking the form of various phases (aqueous, gas and solid), complicated further by variations in influent characteristics, concentrations and flows. To manage these complexities, wastewater process models have been developed over the last three decades from stand-alone models for individual process units to plant-wide computational steady-state and dynamic models, which cater for a broad spectrum of wastewater engineering objectives. Steady-state models are powerful as they comprise simple and explicit algebraic equations that easily allow the estimation of design requirements and operation requirements for a WWTW with much less input information than dynamic models. They are often pre-processers to the dynamic models. In contrast, dynamic models require detailed input formation and sophisticated mathematical solvers but are more accurate in predicting effluent quality, system responses to dynamic conditions and the inhibitory effects of pH, temperature and metabolic products. The decision of selecting a steady-state or dynamic-state model is influenced by several factors, such as available information and influent data, user competency and modelling experience, size and complexity of the plant, as well as the detail and accuracy required by the designer. Wastewater process models therefore serve as a valuable tool for design, optimisation and operational and control strategies.
- ItemOpen AccessDesign of an integrated fixed-film activated sludge (IFAS) system for possible application at the Borcherds Quarry WWTW(2018) Kritzinger, Marco; Ekama, GeorgeNitrification can be seen as the weakness of a conventional activated sludge (CAS) process employing biological nutrient removal (BNR). Suspended nitrifiers only grow in the aerobic zone of the biological reactor but are subjected to anaerobic and anoxic conditions where no nitrifier growth takes place. To establish a nitrifier population that consistently produces low effluent ammonia concentrations, long sludge ages are required (about 15 to 25 days) in South African BNR wastewater treatment plants. This results in relatively large biological reactors. Integrated Fixed-Film Activated Sludge (IFAS) systems have been used extensively in European and Scandinavian countries. This process entails the addition of moving-bed biofilm carriers in certain zones of an activated sludge system to establish biofilm growth. The most successful application has been the addition of these carriers in the aerobic zones of activated sludge plants to facilitate the growth of nitrifiers on the biofilm. This allows nitrifiers to grow independently from the suspended sludge age since it remains stationary on the biofilm in the aerobic tank. The system is thereby relieved from the requirement of a long suspended sludge age. For the University of Cape Town (UCT) process commonly employed in South Africa, it is shown that a suspended sludge age of 5 to 7 days is adequate to meet final effluent standards when converted to an IFAS process. As a result, an UCT-IFAS process can treat 50% to 70% more wastewater in an existing process volume or reduce the size required for a new installation by 30% to 40% when compared to a conventional UCT process with a minimum wastewater temperature of 14°C. The intricacies and challenges associated with designing an IFAS process are unpacked in this thesis to gain a better understanding of what is required to harvest the potential benefits.
- ItemOpen AccessDesktop study on Novel Treatment techniques to treat industrial fertilizer effluent(2018) Fortuin, Jordache; Randall, Dyllon G; Ikumi, DavidFertilizer production is a massive global industry with the global consumption of the three main fertilizer nutrients, nitrogen, phosphate and potassium estimated at 187 million tonnes in 2016 with an anticipated annual growth of approximately 2% for the foreseeable future. In 2016 the global fertilizer market was estimated to have an overall market value of 141 billion US dollars. Fertilizer production produces significant liquid waste as process water used for the various separations, cleaning, emulsifying and dilution processes absorbs various nutrients and contaminants from these production processes. This liquid waste has characteristically high concentrations of nutrients derived from the base fertilizer, such as various dissolved phosphate compounds for phosphate-based fertilizer production or dissolved nitrogenous compounds for nitrogen based fertilizer production. These contaminants are inherently nutrients that could be recovered for beneficial re-use. The phosphate and potassium minerals used in fertilizer production are obtained from ores mined from the earth, thus the re-use of these mineral present particular significance when taking into accounting the declining global supply of these ores. Furthermore, if these liquid wastes are not disposed of correctly they can lead to detrimental environmental impacts such as eutrophication and ecological degradation in water courses. This study addresses this problem by presenting three novel treatment techniques to treat the liquid waste produced from a fertilizer production plant. A liquid waste sample obtained from a particular fertilizer production plant producing primarily nitrogen-based fertilizer is used as a design basis to evaluate the three presented treatment techniques. The techniques are evaluated based on their economic feasibility, technical feasibility and resource recovery ability. The three treatment techniques studied were the Sharon-Anammox bioreaction process, electrodialysis with struvite recovery process and combined forward-reverse osmosis process. The technical feasibility of the processes was primarily evaluated based on the effluent water quality from the treatment systems. The effluent quality index (EQI) was used as a comparative measure of the effluent quality of the processes. All three processes were found to perform inadequately from a technical feasibility perspective as demonstrated by the negative EQI values obtained for the processes. The Sharon-Anammox bioreaction process was found to perform poorly because its application is limited to treatment of waste streams containing high ammonia concentrations such as in conventional domestic waste. Therefore, the Sharon-Anammox process was not suited to the fertilizer effluent which also contained high nitrates, phosphates and total dissolved solids. The electrodialysis process performed poorly as it was unable to effectively remove the ammonium cations from the process water. The combined forward-reverse osmosis process performed poorly because a resource recovery step was not included to treat the concentrated waste stream discharged from the forward osmosis step of the process. It was identified that a similar struvite recovery step should be added to the combined forward-reverse osmosis process to improve the technical feasibility of the process and to provide the process with resource recovery capabilities. From an economic feasibility perspective, it was found that the addition of the struvite recovery setup to the electrodialysis process increased the capital costs of the process to between 300% and 500% of the other two options. However, with the omission of the struvite recovery setup the capital costs of all three processes were in a similar range.
- ItemOpen AccessDevelopment of a Design Tool for Rapid Gravity Media Filtration in Water Treatment(2022) Ingle, Laura; Ikumi, DavidFiltration is the most commonly used water treatment process (Gray, 2010) and can be found at every water treatment plant in South Africa (Van Duuren, F. A., South Africa Water Research Commission., 1997). Therefore, the design, evaluation and improvement of filtration systems is (and should be) ongoing. Currently there is seemingly a lack of consolidated information to enable filter designers to quickly and easily design and evaluate various filtration systems, as it is not always possible to conduct thorough pilot-testing at design stage. This study addresses the development of a detailed filter design tool that enhances the plant-wide water treatment design tool that incorporates a high-level filter design spreadsheet previously developed by Morrison (2019). This study presents guidelines to filter designers for the whole filtration process based on a literature review that consolidates key aspects and design parameters such as media selection and characterisation, filtration rate selection, operation and control, backwash rates, head losses, filter components, configuration and geometry. These parameters are documented in this dissertation and incorporated into the design tool, thus ensuring that the designer obtains relevant insights to the various parameters and their effects. This study focuses on rapid filtration as it is the most common granular filtration technology (Crittenden et al., 2012). The design tool is developed in Microsoft Excel and is intended for exclusive use by the author's employer at the time of submission. The tool itself provides a mechanism for the designer to easily review the effects of various interlinked parameters in developing and refining a filter solution. The outputs of such a tool can be utilised further in plant-wide treatment models.
- ItemOpen Access]Performance of Waste Stabilisation Ponds in the Eastern Cape Province(2023) Tolobisa, Gcina; Ikumi, DavidWater is a scarce natural resource, which requires to be treated with much care and importance. It is a finite resource and should be used sparingly. The process of treating domestic wastewater varies from ponds to the more advanced system, namely the activated sludge system. The main purpose of wastewater treatment is the reduction of pathogenic contamination, coliform bacteria, suspended solids, oxygen demand, and nutrient enrichment. The application or use of stabilisation ponds, as a part of the wastewater treatment process, depends on, among other factors, the influent loading and climate conditions. Waste Stabilisation Ponds (WSPs) are used to biologically treat domestic wastewater or industrial wastewater. The present study focuses on the treatment of domestic wastewater by using the WSPs in the absence of mechanical and electrical equipments. Different countries use different methods of pond design or WSP sizing and different parameters to ensure that the effluent discharge guidelines of the Department of Water and Sanitation (DWS) and World Health Organisation (WHO) are met. There are insufficient literature studies focusing on the design models and water quality data that can be used for sizing the WSPs in South Africa. There is a requirement for a study that can compare the existing WSP design models in different countries and check their suitability for South Africa, particularly their applicability to provinces with respect to climate and domestic wastewater quality. The comparison between the WSP design models will assist the process designers in the early stages of projects, particularly in the feasibility study stages (Scenario 1). The objective of the present study is to perform a comprehensive review of the use of WSPs in domestic wastewater treatment, their design and operating requirements for optimal performance, and the existing mathematical models used to virtually replicate the WSP treatment processes. Also considered is the development of a simplified model to demonstrate its application as a tool for the effective design of WSPs, including a case study of a WSP in the Eastern Cape (EC).
- ItemOpen AccessPrimary sedimentation tank model with characterized settling velocity groups(University of Cape Town, 2020) Polorigni, Christian Leprince; Ikumi, David S; Ekama, George APrimary sedimentation involves the separation of solids and liquid in primary settling tanks (PSTs) of wastewater treatment systems. These physical processes are described by various settling conditions such as discrete and flocculent settling, along with other phenomena such as flocculation, coagulation, ammonification or hydrolysis. The modelling of primary sedimentation has often been overlooked because (i) it involves various intricacies that are difficult to replicate and (ii) primary sedimentation has been assumed to be an input to most of the main unit process models, including the activated sludge (AS) system and the anaerobic digestion (AD) models. Though there has been a wide range of proposed mathematical models to describe how PSTs function, the need to correctly disaggregate the total suspended solids (TSS) into realistic fractions of unbiodegradable particulate organics (UPO), biodegradable particulate organics (BPO) and inorganic settleable solids (ISS), remains. This is because PST models that are unable to correctly split the TSS into its characteristic components make incorrect assumptions. These assumptions lead to inconsistencies in predicting the compositions of the primary sludge (PS) that is fed to the AD unit and the settled wastewater (settled WW) that is treated in the AS system. Hence, it becomes difficult to correctly simulate the entire system (plant-wide) towards a holistic evaluation of system strategies. In this study, a realistic PST model was developed, with characterized settling velocity groups, within a plant-wide setting, for municipal wastewater. This involved the improvement of a current TSS-based model into a more accurate and realistic model that could account for the settling of raw wastewater particles. The model was therefore expected to predict the composition of the PS that is treated in the AD system and the composition of the settled WW that is going to the AS unit processes. This could be achieved by splitting the TSS into UPO, BPO and ISS fractions. In developing preparation of such a realistic PST model, the following objectives were established: 1. Disaggregate the TSS into realistic UPO, BPO and ISS fractions, by means of discrete particle settling modelling (Kowlesser, 2014) and the particle settling velocity distribution (PSVD) approach of Bachis et al. (2015). 2. Verify that the model is internally consistent with wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) data, by means of mathematical material mass balances and other specific scenarios. 3. Demonstrate the application and impact of such a model by performing steady state plant-wide simulations. Using the discrete particle settling approach of Kowlesser (2014), a discrete particle settling model was developed in Microsoft Excel and implemented into a dynamic PST framework in WEST® (Vanhooren et al., 2003). The discrete particle settling model was described using steady state and dynamic calculations and the insights obtained from these calculations were implemented in the current TSS-based PST model of Bachis et al. (2015). This was performed towards developing the University of Cape Town Primary Sedimentation Unit (UCTPSU). The influent raw wastewater TSS was fractionated into UPO, BPO and ISS fractions and settling proportions of these fractions were assigned to five settling velocity groups. In addition, a distinct settling velocity was assigned to each settling velocity group. Previous studies data from WRC (1984) and Ekama (2017), were used in the discrete particle settling model, which was able to reproduce PS and settled WW outputs, through steady state and dynamic calculations and under strict material mass balances. As a result, UPO, BPO and ISS settling proportions as well as settling velocities, were extracted from these calculations and used as input parameters into the UCTPSU model. This dynamic model was rigorously verified to be internally consistent with regards to strict material mass balances. The verification scenarios also included variations of high and low settling velocities as well as a combination of both high and low velocities and checking that the model was behaving as expected. The application and impact of the UCTPSU model were demonstrated using plant-wide scenarios in proposing a preliminary integration, under steady state conditions. It showed how incorrect disaggregation of the TSS into UPO, BPO and ISS fractions can lead to incorrect predictions in terms of the settled WW composition, the AS system capacity, the effluent quality, as well as the energy consumption and generation in the AS system and AD unit respectively. The investigation also revealed the need to measure key wastewater parameters such as particle settling velocities and the unbiodegradable particulate COD fraction, when it comes to realistically modelling of primary sedimentation of municipal wastewater, with the view of optimizing plant operations and tactical decision making. The study thereafter recommended the need to conduct an extensive experimental campaign to measure in-situ diurnal data, mainly in terms of settling velocities and settling proportions of UPO, BPO and ISS. It was also suggested to use the settleometer as a tool to extract these settling velocities and settling proportions, after performing biodegradability tests. As such, the data collected from the experimental campaign and the biodegradability tests could be used in calibrating the UCTPSU model and validation could be undertaken by means of full plant scale data.
- ItemOpen AccessRe-coding of UCTPHO and UCTOLD in Visual Basic for Applications(2016) De Swardt, Gerard; Ekama, George AUCTOLD, IAWPRC and UCTPHO are activated sludge system diurnal simulation software programs written and compiled in TurboPascal 3.1 by the Water Research Group at the University of Cape Town in the late 1980s and early 1990s. IAWPRC is identical to International Water Association (IWA) Activated sludge Model No 1 (ASM1, Henze et al., 1987) and UCTOLD is an earlier variation of ASM1 that makes no material difference to simulation results when each are run with their default parameters – the difference is explained by Dold and Marais (1985). Details on the use of UCTOLD and IAWPRC was published by Dold et al. (1991) and this guide remains essential reading for the responsible use of the recoded UCTOLD and UCTPHO presented in this thesis. In the early 1990s, when the kinetics of phosphorus accumulating organisms (PAO) were sufficiently well understood, biological excess P removal (BEPR) was added to UCTOLD to yield UCTPHO. This software has the same look and feel as UCTOLD/IAWPRC and so a guide for it was never published. Details of the BEPR research that was codified into it are given by Wentzel et al. (1991) and Clayton et al. (1991). Later, much of the Wentzel BEPR model was integrated into ASM1 to form ASM2 (Henze et al., 1995). So UCTPHO and ASM2 differ in the same way as UCTOLD and ASM1/IAWPRC differ, essentially only in the fate of the product of the hydrolysis of slowly biodegradable particulate organics (BPO) – in ASM1/2, this product enters the bulk liquid as readily biodegradable soluble organics (BSO) with the ordinary heterotrophic organisms (OHO) utilizing only BSO, whereas in UCTOLD/UCTPHO the BPO product is utilized directly by the OHO and so does not enter the bulk liquid (Dold and Marais, 1985). One aspect is very important to note about the models embedded in these codes – UCTOLD and ASM1 are only for biological N removal systems and UCTPHO and ASM2 are only for biological N and P removal systems. One cannot simulate a N and P removal system with UCTOLD (or ASM1) and one cannot simulate a N removal system only with UCTPHO (or ASM2). The kinetics of denitrification in UCTOLD/ASM1 and UCTPHO/ASM2 are not the same - the details of the differences are explained by Clayton et al. (1991). For two decades up to around 2010, UCTOLD and UCTPHO provided free activated sludge system simulation tools to consultants, municipalities and operators to predict the performance of the activated sludge systems of wastewater treatment plants. Therefore smaller consultancies had the software available for use without requiring expensive commercial software for the modelling of household/municipal wastewater. With the advancement of computer hardware and Windows operating systems over two decades, the UCTOLD and UCTPHO software (not the models coded within them) grew outdated and gradually lost functionality. Then when 64 bit processor personal computers (PC) became available, the old compiled TurboPascal 3.1 software could no longer be run – they can still run on 32 bit processor WinXP PCs. Re-coding the software was therefore required if the continued use of the software were to be ensured. This recoding into Excel/VBA was undertaken in this thesis. Some considerable effort also went into the improvement of the user interface. The new interface allows quick input and configuration of the biological reactors of the activated sludge system, and the recycle streams. Several challenges presented themselves during the recoding stage of the project, most notable of which were the data management structures and the calculation time minimisation. Also, significant time was also spent on simulations to determine the effects of the integration parameters on calculation time, and to determine how to minimise the calculation time. After struggling with these challenges for some months, the recoded programs started to present results similar to the original TurboPascal compiled code, about a year after commencement with the project. This Beta version has the same functionality that the original Turbo Pascal versions had including Adjustment of the Wastage Pattern and Graphical Display of Diurnal Results. The calculation of activated sludge ISS concentration was added as an option by including the influent OHO and PAO ISS to determine reactor TSS concentration for N and N&P removal systems using results from Ekama and Wentzel (2004). So, instead of having to enter an activated sludge VSS/TSS ratio, the option to calculate it from entered influent VSS and TSS data can now be selected to calculate the reactor TSS concentration.
- ItemOpen AccessThe feasibility of augmenting the Stellenbosch potable water supply by establishing a direct potable reuse plant(2019) Raubenheimer, Murray; Ekama, GeorgeThe Western Cape has suffered severe droughts over the past decade which has placed severe strain on raw water resources for both agriculture and municipal use. The crisis was due to many factors including climate change, increasing urbanisation and ageing infrastructure to name a few. The water scarcity problems will persist in the future globally unless water management authorities are able to augment existing raw water resources with a mix of desalination, groundwater and reclamation of treated effluent. The town of Stellenbosch was selected as part of a case study to determine the feasibility of implementing a direct potable reuse (DPR) plant to augment the future water resource mix from a technical, social, environmental and economic standpoint. Over the past two decades there has been a global shift towards direct and indirect potable reuse schemes to augment existing surface and groundwater resources. The shift has been accelerated by advances in treatment technology, water quality monitoring and research which have reduced the costs of potable reuse when compared to conventional water resources. The effluent from the Stellenbosch Wastewater Treatment Works was investigated as a reliable raw feed water source for the Stellenbosch DPR Plant. The Stellenbosch DPR Plant treatment train followed the multiple barrier approach to ensure high quality product water and mitigate potential risks to human health. The process design favoured granular activated carbon filtration instead of reverse osmosis due to the lower costs, inland location and brine disposal issues along with the acceptable total dissolved salt levels within the source water. The process design was developed further to determine the energy consumption, chemical consumption and process monitoring and control framework for the plant. A technical feasibility was done on three scenarios which were selected based on mix of reclaimed water and current surface water resources to supply the town of Stellenbosch with potable water. Scenario A – ‘do-nothing’ approach whereby the Stellenbosch Municipality would continue to be supplied with bulk raw water from the Theewaterskloof Dam treat it at the Paradyskloof WTW Scenario B – DPR Plant which produced potable water and injected it upstream of the Paradyskloof WTW Scenario C - DPR Plant which produced potable water and injected it downstream of the Paradyskloof WTW The research found that it would be feasible to implement a DPR scheme in Stellenbosch to improve the towns’ water security to meet future demands. The technical, social and environmental issues introduced in this research would need to be considered and developed further once a decision was made to pursue DPR. The unit costs of DPR would be higher than expanding the current raw surface water allocation and conventional water treatment works, which would have a knock-on effect on consumer tariffs. These economic costs would need to be compared to the towns risk exposure to climate change and water demands from surrounding areas within the Western Cape should they continue to abstract water from surface water resource not under their control.
- ItemOpen AccessTreating wastewater in a conventional activated sludge (CAS) system or a Membrane Bioreactor (MBR). A comparison of capital and operating costs(2020) Smith, Delwin; Ekama, GeorgeMore and more focus is going into the establishment of more sustainable approaches for wastewater treatment (WWT) in South Africa, as well as around the world. Governments are beginning to enforce more economical solutions for WWT, which will have less impact on costs as well as land area requirements. Effective solid-liquid separation in biological wastewater treatment is an important step in the process as it has a major impact on effluent quality. Traditionally this has been achieved using Secondary settling tanks (SSTs) for liquid/solid separation in combination with a biological reactor (for biological degradation of organic matter). SSTs, however, require a large space, which becomes onerous on land requirements. In an immersed membrane bioreactor (iMBR), solid-liquid separation takes place by the wastewater passing through membranes. As the WW flows through, at the same time solids are rejected by the membranes. These membranes are immersed in the bioreactor. iMBR thus eliminates the requirement for SSTs and are becoming more widely used to treat various types of wastewater, due to the decreasing cost of membranes and the resultant reduced plant footprint. MBR is thus becoming an attractive solution to clients due to its sustainable approach. As part of this investigation, 2 types of MBR technology were included, the Kubota FS MBR system and the Zeeweed HF MBR system. As the design of a CAS is sensitive to sludge settleability, various DSVI values were looked at as part of the CAS system. Each system was configured in an MLE and UCT process. In summary, the following systems were included in this investigation: • CAS in an MLE configuration with DSVI of 100,150 and 200 • CAS in a UCT configuration with DSVI of 100,150 and 200 • iMBR using FS membranes in an MLE configuration • iMBR using FS membranes in a UCT configuration • iMBR using HF membranes in an MLE configuration • iMBR using HF membranes in a UCT configuration Each process configuration was designed and sized using the steady state models. Each configuration was then fully costed using actual construction prices from past and current projects. Costing of the MBR systems were done in conjunction with the membrane suppliers who also provided valuable design input. The selection of design MLSS in an MBR and CAS has a significant impact on the reactor and SST size. The MLSS concentration also has an impact on the alpha factor which influences aeration efficiency. As part of this investigation, an optimum MLSS concentration (MLSSopt) cost optimization was done taking into account the effect on reactor size, SST area, membrane area, and aeration CAPEX and OPEX. This resulted in an MLSSopt of 5 500 mg/l and 6 000 mg/l for the CAS MLE and CAS UCT respectively, and 10 000 mg/l for the Zeeweed MBR and Kubota MBR system. The CAS system had the lowest total cost (CAPEX+OPEX) of the 3 systems over a lifespan of 10 years, with the Zeeweed MBR having the 2 nd lowest cost coming in at 61% higher than the CAS system. The Kubota MBR had the highest total cost with a 203% higher cost than the CAS system. In terms of land area requirement, the Kubota MBR required the least amount of land area, followed by the Zeeweed MBR which required 12% more land space. The CAS system required 127-514% more land space at the various DSVI values than the Kubota system. This was due to the additional SST area and a larger reactor requirement.