Browsing by Author "van de Spuy, Elrena"

Now showing 1 - 2 of 2
  • Thumbnail Image
    Item
    Open Access
    Deconstructing Gangsterism in the Western Cape Policy Response to the National Anti-Gangsterism Strategy
    (2020) Viltoft, Clara Dybbroe; van de Spuy, Elrena
    In the Province of the Western Cape in South Africa, gangsterism continues to be associated with issues of violence, crime and localised conflicts, affecting residents on the Cape Flats in particular. Although the country's legal framework promotes human rights and despite ongoing interventions by law enforcement, the effectiveness of government responses is still debated by politicians as well as the general public. Using Carol Bacchi's ‘What's the Problem Represented to Be' (2009) approach to policy analysis, the aim of this dissertation is to deconstruct the Western Cape's political problematisation and representation of the ‘problem' by analysing the Western Cape Provincial Policy response to the National Anti-Gangsterism Strategy. From a social constructivist angle, this dissertation presumes policy as prescriptive guidelines that dictate action. Further, the aim is to discover how the problem is understood and represented and thus analyse which discourses and material responses are generated and which are not. The findings confirm that there is a discrepancy between what is articulated in policy and what actually happens on the ground, i.e. between discourse and practice. Moreover, it will be argued that sustained anti-gang intervention demand that structural obstacles and inequality in lieu of the spill over from the Apartheid era are addressed. Taking notice of these aspects, the minor dissertation concludes that it is critical to figure out how best to transform conflict conditions in areas with high levels of gang violence with the view to allowing both youth groups and individuals to exert agency and become empowered in pursuit of individual and community resilience.
  • Thumbnail Image
    Item
    Open Access
    The Role of Regional Organisations in Upholding Credible and Legitimate Electoral Processes in Africa
    (2020) Mbanje, Tendai Shephard; van de Spuy, Elrena; Wachira, George Mukundi
    Regional Organizations hereinafter referred as Regional Economic Communities (RECs) are the building blocks of the African Union. They promote regional integration, democratization, cooperation, development and peace and security within African States. RECs complement the instruments of the AU on democracy consolidation and its shared norms and values. Since elections are at the centre for democracy, development and human rights, RECs have a mandate to protect and promote them. Protection and promotion of democratic elections have become a priority among the RECs. RECs have adopted legal instruments to protect democratic elections. They observe elections within Member States. They effectively conduct pre- and post-electoral audits to facilitate smooth conduct of elections. They facilitate mediation when electoral disputes arise. RECs also facilitate political negotiations and dialogues in times of electoral conflicts. They enhance restoration of democracy when it is violated. They assist with interventions when governments act unconstitutionally and refuse to step down from power. In some cases, they impose sanctions, where necessary, to states violating democracy and human rights. Thus, the role of the RECs is dynamic and has been expanding over the years to meet the needs of their regions. However, despite the establishment of RECs, and their mandates in supporting consolidation of democracy, election disputes have been prevalent in Africa. Electoral malpractices have been in the form of vote rigging, manipulation of vote results, refusal of incumbent heads of state to step down after losing elections to mention a few. This happened in the Gambia in 2016 as discussed in this study. In some cases, independent electoral commissions have committed gross errors in vote counting as in the case of Zimbabwe 2018 elections. These errors have caused election disputes and political uprisings. Election monitoring bodies have also failed to provide accurate reports on the outcome and conduct of elections and have caused a cycle of contested elections in some African countries. The case of the SADC Observer Mission in Zimbabwe is a good example in this study. Elections that have lacked credibility and integrity have led to crises of legitimacy in governance. The lack of legitimacy and credibility of elections have undermined human rights and freedoms linked to democratic elections. This research argues that contestations over elections should not be seen in isolation from the entire human rights discourse. Human rights are interdependent and, therefore, when one right is affected other rights suffer in turn. Protection of a single right such as, the right to vote, has a positive impact to the realisation of many human rights.