Browsing by Author "Scott, Tanya"

Now showing 1 - 2 of 2
  • No Thumbnail Available
    Item
    Open Access
    A contribution to understanding the primary moult of birds
    (2023) Scott, Tanya; Underhill, Leslie; Erni Birgit
    Moult is an essential component of the annual cycle of birds, along with breeding, and, if migratory, migration. The leading statistical model for the analysis of primary moult is the Underhill-Zucchini moult model. It estimates moult parameters (duration, the mean start date and its standard deviation). An objective of this thesis was to assemble all published results which had used the UnderhillZucchini moult and to examine the resulting database for patterns in the timing, duration and synchronisation of moult. A total of 242 analyses of 136 species were found. The initial analysis of the database generated two observations: firstly, that latitude played an important role in determining patterns of primary moult, and, secondly, that the available data were latitudinally, spatially across continents, and taxonomically not representative. These gaps in knowledge were too large to rectify within the confines of a single PhD thesis. The preliminary chapters of the thesis added 18 analyses, for 11 species, and have made a contribution towards representativity. Two of the preliminary chapters make substantive contributions to the methods of undertaking statistical studies of moult. A new moult index, the Relative Duration Index, is introduced. Moult studies are frequently undertaken by combining datasets collected in different years (or different places). This thesis contains the first practical application of a proposed method to identify which of the individual datasets have a large influence of the estimates of the moult parameters. Nine analyses extended the latitudinal range of studies southwards and were based on datasets assembled in New Zealand. These are the first analyses of primary moult using the UnderhillZucchini moult model from this country. For seven species, this thesis undertakes moult studies of a species in both its original country, the United Kingdom, and the country into which it had been introduced, New Zealand. These are the first analyses of primary moult of this kind. Preliminary patterns of moult strategies are discussed. Critical gaps in our understanding of primary moult are identified. Priorities for fieldwork and analysis are described in order that key gaps are filled and a global review of primary moult can be undertaken.
  • Thumbnail Image
    Item
    Open Access
    Birds along a transect across KwaZulu-Natal: altitudinal preference and altitudinal migration
    (2018) Scott, Tanya; Underhill, Leslie G
    The special ornithological advantage of KwaZulu-Natal is the massive altitudinal gradient between the coastline and the Drakensberg Mountains, an altitudinal range in excess of 3000 m. It is one of the best places in the world to study altitudinal bird migration. This dissertation uses the bird data from the Second Southern African Bird Atlas Project (SABAP2), and altitudinal data from a Digital Elevation Model to try to understand altitudinal migration in a band of KwaZulu-Natal between 29°S and 30°S. The bird atlas provides data on a five minute grid, grid cells with sides of c. 9km, known as pentads. The Digital Elevation Model gives spot heights at 0.5 minute intervals. It therefore provides 100 altitudes in each pentad. There is a description of the data analysis approach used to relate bird species abundance to altitude and selected examples to show how the method works, illustrating the strengths and weakness of the approach. The developed method is then applied to the study area to investigate altitudinal migration. For each of the 304 species which occur with some regularity in the study area, the altitudinal height preferences in summer and winter are plotted and compared. Some species, such as African Dusky Flycatcher, are definite altitudinal migrants, and some species are definite residents having essentially identical altitudinal distributions in summer and winter, such as Black-bellied Starling. There are also many intermediate strategies. Numerous species have been proposed as altitudinal migrants in KwaZulu-Natal. These claims are evaluated against the results obtains in this dissertation. For some species, the suggestion that they are altitudinal migrants is clearly incorrect, and for other species the hypotheses are confirmed by the bird atlas data. The project attempted to determine if there were common factors that helped explain which species engaged in altitudinal migration. A set of life history characteristics for each species, including aspects such as diet, mass, habitat, etc, was used to evaluate if there was a relationship between the extent of altitudinal migration and these explanatory variables. No meaningful relationships were found. Explanations of altitudinal migrations therefore remain an enigma.